Be young and shut up

A blog about student activism.

Stop talking about rape and start listening

with 11 comments

Trigger warning for descriptions of sexual harrassment and references to sexual violence.

In the past few days I have been watching the explosion on Twitter and Facebook and comment sites about Dominique Strauss-Kahn’s trial and the comments of Kenneth Clarke.

The vast majority of those commenting have been men, some of whom were declaring their disgust and being allies, which I welcome, but some have been men questioning women’s experiences, questioning the seriousness of rape, questioning if what Clarke said was actually ‘that bad’.

For clarity, yes it fucking was. By talking about ‘proper’, serious’, ‘classic rape’, which is apparently men jumping out of bushes, he trivialised non-stranger rape, including rape in relationships, incest, and rape from friends – the vast majority of rapes (91%). He also trivialised the importance of age of consent laws and apparently didn’t even know that they have been changed – having sex with someone between the ages of thirteen and sixteen does not necessarily constitute statutory rape anymore.

Perhaps Clarke is ignorant, but as in the courts, ignorance is no defence. He got involved in a debate about rape, and showed real arrogance, thinking that because he has met rape victims he somehow understands. Do some reading and now some listening, Mr Clarke.

I am a rape victim, Ken Clarke, and what you said upset me to the point where I was standing outside my university library at 1.30am, shaking, screaming, wailing and crying, because I was so perturbed by your comments and some people’s reactions to them. But then perhaps I am just an emotional woman.

He could never understand the daily experience that a lot of women and people of other genders suffer. Here I am only going to cover what it feels like to be a woman because as a cisgendered woman that is the only experience I have and I will let trans, intersexed, neutrois, androgyne etc people speak for themselves.

Since I was about eleven years old, some boys and men have treated my body as if it is not my own. They have slapped me, grabbed parts of me without invitation or flirtation, catcalled me, made me move so they could get a better view of my body parts, commented on what I’m wearing and my weight and looks. Men who have fancied me have sometimes made me feel guilty for not wanting to kiss or sleep with them, they have made me feel guilty for not dealing with their sexual frustration, they have made me feel like a ‘bitch’ for not fancying them back.

A lot of my previous boyfriends have either made me, or made me feel guilty if I didn’t (which almost amounts to the same thing), have sex with them or give them blowjobs. The persuasion that they engaged in made me feel sick and dirty, used and violated.

I have been what I see as sexually assaulted several times, within the legal definition of sexual assault occurring at least a few times. A man forced me to give him oral sex when I was eighteen. That was the worst. But I have also had men intruding upon my vagina, trying to stimulate me so I would have sex with them when I didn’t want to, and have forced me to give them handjobs.

And I have been raped. By someone I was in a relationship with. It is only recently I realised it was rape, but I didn’t want to have sex, I said I didn’t want to, but then he continued to kiss me and stimulate me and ultimately penetrate me. It has made it hard for me to trust people, it means that my memories are often triggered by debate like that we have seen in the last few days, and it will be with me for the rest of my life.

But adding to the initial trauma is the reaction to rape within society. It tends to be either paternalistic – ‘oh poor you, what a bastard, he should be locked up for life/killed/castrated’… Or blaze – ‘ah it isn’t that bad, you probably wanted it really; women who are drunk/ scantily clad/ slutty bring it on themselves. Both of these are awful and I don’t actually have that much of a problem with Clarke’s proposals. It was his language and comments that were deeply offensive and upsetting. The Daily Mail somehow manages to both maximise and minimise rape with a combination of sensationalist articles and slut-blaming comment pieces, thanks to the likes of Melanie Philips, Liz Jones, Richard Littlejohn, et al. To be clear, I don’t think the man who raped me was evil, he is a man who did something wrong. I don’t want him to be killed, castrated or locked up for life, I just wish I could have made him understand how I feel. For other women this is different and I respect their wishes with regard to legal proceedings – it is a disgrace that only 6% or reported rapes in England and Wales and 4% in Scotland end in conviction. And think about how many people, like me, don’t report it. We are in a rape epidemic. The statistics say 10% of women are or have been raped but I believe it is probably more.

But even those who have never forced themselves upon women like me or sexually assaulted or harassed anyone, they still need to watch themselves.

Every time a man catcalls me, comments on my breasts in a perverted way (clue: I often don’t mind when gay men say I have nice breasts, I mind a lot more when it’s straight men), it brings back the countless horrible memories and experiences I have had. Every time someone makes a joke about rape, whether it’s something as benign as ‘fraping’ or something like making that joke about rape not being rape when you shout ‘surprise!’, I feel physically fucking sick. Every time someone talks about rape casually, as if it is an open topic for everyone to discuss, I feel like punching someone’s lights out. Every time a man ignores me, doesn’t listen to my opinions, belittles me or berates my agency, I feel like an object, I feel undermined, I feel violated.

My experiences are my own, I don’t want people to feel sorry for me, I want you all to be fucking enraged that this is the daily experience of a 22-year-old woman, I want you to be fucking enraged that I have been suffering this kind of shit since I was eleven years old, I want you all to go out and do something about it.

I am somebody you know and possibly love, I am a real person with opinions on a wide range of subjects, not just a passive person you can ignore because you don’t know them. I do not meet the typical ‘victim’ stereotype, I am openly feminist (and have been since I was 11), angry and loud, and yet I suffer this.

Please believe me, respect my experiences, and campaign with me.

In solidarity

Kate

I want this to be spread as widely as possible. Please re-post, re-publish, anything. Email me at katelizharris@gmail.com

P.S. Thank you to the incredible sister-in-solidarity who picked up the pieces last night. You know who you are. I love you.

Advertisements

Written by CakeCakeCakeCakeCake

May 19, 2011 at 11:17 pm

Posted in Uncategorized

11 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. I came across this post on the Bright Green site (http://brightgreenscotland.org/).

    I must confess that before reading this piece I have felt angered at the barely concealed glea of some at a chance to attack a political oponent. Angered by the misrepresentation of an arguement that Ken Clarke garbled with his inarticulate bumbling in the radio interview. Angered by the co-opting of an important debate over sentence guidelines, criminal justice, penal reform, offender rehabilitation, and the purpose of prison.

    Having read this I still feel angry, but mostly I feel sick. It is a hollow empty nausea of incomprehension; a gnawing certainty that for all my opinions, bluster and good intentions I remain fundamentaly ignorant to people’s suffering.

    Campaign with you? Absolutely.

    Jack

    May 20, 2011 at 3:20 pm

    • I’m ignorant to many other forms of suffering so I can sympathise. I’ve never really known what it’s like to be truly poor, as just one example.
      Very glad to have you as an ally. I hope you’ll get involved with feminist campaigning – many SlutWalks and Reclaim the Night events are coming up.
      Thank you for your solidarity. Kate

      Kate Harris

      May 20, 2011 at 3:23 pm

  2. I don’t know how I came to read this — I suspect from Shakesville, but there may have been intermediate steps — but an excellent piece, well worth reading, and I will link it from places I write in and hope it gets more of an audience. Thank you.

    Matthew Brown

    May 21, 2011 at 2:41 am

  3. Found this via Bright Green – I’m not sure what to say other than I agree with you completely and that I found this interesting to read.

    wearealllivingin1984

    May 21, 2011 at 11:03 pm

  4. Just got round to reading this as I catch up on my blogs. You have my anger – help me direct it.

    doobarz

    May 22, 2011 at 2:48 pm

  5. […] you read the perspectives of individuals at either end of the spectrum – say, for example, this courageous and very personal post from Kate Harris and this pretty offensive post from MEP Roger Helmer – it is clear that there is still a very […]

  6. really inspired by this post. i stayed on my friend’s floor one night after locking myself out of my room and was woken up by being sexually assaulted in my sleep in my first year of university.after being trivialized by the first person i told, i haven’t shared it with many people at all since. on a rational level i knew i did nothing wrong, yet their reactions turned me to a lot of emotional guilt and questioning of myself and whether i’d done anything to mislead or imply anything (the black and white is that i was fully asleep and was woken up by what he was doing to me which means there was not really any possible way i could have done). 4 years on and this still affects certain aspects of my life profoundly, including friendships and relationships alike. yet i’m trapped into secrecy because i find it hard to know who i can trust. i’m also a very private person and find personal things difficult to talk through unless i know people extremely well (and this is all very catch 22- trust issues often prevent me ever showing enough of myself to let people get to know me, and defensiveness can often make me seem plain rude or uncaring). i am incredibly insulted by ken clarke’s comments. i still fail to see the rationale behind society’s insistence that women “cry rape” or that it isn’t an issue which effects people seriously when victims are regularly treated with such contempt. i didn’t almost quit my university degree (i eventually decided i would return only due to one very supportive member of staff who made me see start seeing it was possible and referred me to counseling), lose the several hundred pounds of flights i had booked for travel plans i cancelled due to total loss of confidence or have panic attacks in clubs for a good while afterwards for the sake of making up a story. yet our mutual friends seemed to assume that since he was religious and i was “capable of that kind of thing” (by which i can only assume they refer to the fact that i’d kissed a few people that term, though i was still a virgin at the time) it must just be a misunderstanding. i think in many respects it was their reaction to the situation that was harder to take than the event itself. and it is certainly their reaction which has pushed me into secrecy and defensiveness with other friends now. thanks for being bold enough to stand up and speak out about this, i wish i could be as brave.

    anon

    May 23, 2011 at 9:20 pm

    • Solidarity. Your story is shocking. There are so many amazing people like you who have to cope with the consequences of someone else’s vile actions every day. Stay strong and remember, it had nothing to do with you, so try not to let it affect your sense of self xx

      Kate Harris

      August 4, 2011 at 10:06 pm

  7. […] I’ve written about my experiences with men who use their privilege to be violent and coercive here. […]

  8. I feel like I wrote this, our experiences are so similar.

    charlotte

    August 23, 2012 at 9:02 am

  9. […] It started when I was eleven. I talk more about my experiences here. […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: